Feeds:
Posts
Comments

OpenID continues…

Not only am I in some cases prevented from leaving comments on locked LJ posts, but in leaving a comment on an unlocked post I had to pass through a captcha and have my posting of a link sanitized into unclickability. What indignity! Being an OpenID user, sadly, appears to make one a second class netizen in LJ-land.

I would recommend, for anyone looking for a smooth transition, that they not go with OpenID. It is not smooth. I’m sticking with it for my own reasons, but frankly, maintaining accounts on every journal system in common use would be simpler and less hassle.

OpenID and not quite

I had hoped that folks would be able to comment on this blog using OpenID. Keyword here is hope – it didn’t turn out to be the case. While WordPress is a producer of OpenID identities, it is not a consumer of them. There is no capacity to log into WordPress using OpenID or to use it when leaving comments on a post on WordPress. Apparently, if I had moved to Blogger, you would not be inconvenienced in this way. Tough beans. I’ve left anonymous comments open.

LiveJournal’s support of OpenID is more complete, but still lacks in one respect: I can’t find any way to get emails when people reply to my comments there. So, if I miss something you’d rather I paid attention to, ping me about it.

One reason I make a good test case for this is that my life is in a minor amiable upheaval at the moment. A slight attrition rate won’t bother me much. I’m going to work hard at keeping track of everyone and keeping up with all of them, wherever they blog, as well as broadening my reading base by looking for interesting journals in other places, but I don’t actually expect this to completely succeed. I will try to keep my blog findable and easy to access, but I don’t expect everyone will agree with my definition of easy. Getting slightly ahead of the technology is never as simple as it looks.

It quite snuck up on me, this idea of leaving LiveJournal. Once I started on it, it seemed quite fun, but only because I’m willing to lose a little to gain a bit right now. And I have lost some – filtering functionality, ease of integration, etc. But I’ve also gained, because LiveJournal was culturally not entirely my sort of place anyway, even before the recent transitions. So, how is the first round of this going?

OpenID – Doesn’t do all I would wish it to, not by half. But it does provide a base on which other technologies could build, and it does get my non-LJ URL onto people’s screens. Its implementation is far too much like having a LiveJournal account that just happens to send its login info to a different site, rather than true cross-site integration, but that’s passable, at least for me.

Filtering – If I’d wanted to make it easy on myself, I would have gone to another site that used LiveJournal’s software, so as to have the equivalent “friends” concept and associated filtering. Here, I don’t have that, but it was a conscious choice to not want it right now, and to want something culturally different. This has more to do with my current life shifts than with leaving LiveJournal, but also means that I get to be a test case of integration across different software suites.

RSS – I already use in a lot of cases and will likely use in more. It’s a lovely technology. I ought to look for better clients for it though, as there’s a chance of some of them supporting OpenID or login cookies, either of which would be sufficient to get me at the locked LiveJournal posts I read. Aside from locked stuff, it looks like RSS is going to be my way of handling “friends page” equivalence.

This is more pinning together disparate pieces than the previous solution, but at the same time it’s a little like stepping out of AOL into the real internet. There’s a world out here, and it’s a tiny bit complicated, but I suspect it’s worth while. Of course, I’m not the only person I’m inconveniencing, and social networking is never trivial or linear, so only time will really tell.

Integration test

Because nothing about this process is obvious…

« Newer Posts